Dr. JJ Allen, PharmD

Topics

Supplements without the hype

What's worth taking, what's junk, and how to read a label like someone who has made them.

General education, not medical advice. Talk with your doctor or pharmacist before you change anything.

A lot of supplements are very helpful and a lot are junk. The loudest voices are often the companies selling them. On the other side are busy doctors who say "it's just expensive urine." The truth has more nuance.

I've seen supplements from the other side of the bottle. With Sean Casey, RD, I helped create the products for Evolve Wellness. Picking ingredients and forms, vetting manufacturers, reviewing third party testing and labels. It taught me how to spot quality from first principles.

Start with the word supplement

What's missing from your diet? In Wisconsin, three come up again and again.

  1. Vitamin D. Nobody here gets enough sun. Test your level, then supplement to fill the gap. I like to see a 25-hydroxyvitamin D level of 45 to 65 ng/mL.
  2. Magnesium. Not enough leafy greens, and soil has less than it used to. Skip the cheap magnesium oxide. It doesn't absorb well. I like a blend of citrate, malate and glycinate.
  3. Omega-3. Few of us eat enough small fatty fish like sardines, mackerel, anchovies, salmon and herring.

Can you take too many?

Yes. Many supplements are low risk. But at high doses some act like drugs. The fat soluble vitamins A, D and E build up and can cause harm. One person might truly need six supplements. Someone else needs two and nothing else. You can find someone online selling a reason to take a hundred.

How I pick one I trust

  1. Read the Supplement Facts box. Each ingredient should have its own line and amount. If it says "proprietary blend," you can't tell if the dose is meaningful. Pick a different product.
  2. Find a pharmacist or practitioner you trust who vets brands.
  3. Look for trusted branded raw materials, like Albion TRAACS for magnesium glycinate.
  4. Buy direct from the company, a pharmacy or a practitioner. There are counterfeits online, especially on expensive products.

"Pharmaceutical grade" on a label isn't governed by anyone. Seals like USP and NSF are a good sign, but not a guarantee.

Articles on this

The TranslatorDr. JJ Allen, PharmD

One useful email, when I've got one worth sending.

Start with my free cheat sheet, Is your medicine draining you? Common prescriptions, the nutrients they can run low, and the one question to ask about each.

  • Qty: a couple a month, never more than one a week
  • Refills: unlimited
  • Cost: free

Unsubscribe anytime. Please don't send health details. Privacy

Other topics